(Source: Yeldon, Accountancy, October 1999, Pg.106)
- Forms part of the company's strengths and weaknesses or 'position audit' and breaks the business/company products down into 4 groups, based on:
- RELATIVE MARKET SHARE
(measure against strongest competitor, market share an indicator of cash-generating ability)
- INDUSTRY GROWTH RATE
(measure of cash use, expanding market will require investment in capital equipment and marketing
THE FOUR GROUPS ARE
- PROBLEM CHILD/QUESTION MARKS
, low market share in rapidly expanding industry
- STAR
, high share of a growing market, will produce cash, but much eaten up by investment to sustain growth
- CASH
COW, should produce cash due to its market status and will require less investment
- DOG
, require little investment, but unlikely to generate much cash itself
SEVERAL POINTS TO CONSIDER:
- Business needs cash cows, they provide cash to develop business
- Hope that question marks can be promoted into stars (if sufficient cash available)
- As life cycle slows, they will ultimately turn into cash cows
- Balance is needed, cash cows (may make money) but eventually turn into dogs
- There must be question marks in need of development
- If there are many, must decide which to fund to turn them into stars
- Dogs should either be managed effectively to maximise generated cash
- ...or divested to produce cash to grow stars
PROBLEMS
- The model will not tell you which question marks deserve investment or which dogs to sell or retain
- You need to interact with the world, and so use as a starting block, to other models
- Hence, use Porter's five forces:
- Look for barriers to entry, if you have these a business may be worth building or easier to sell (harder to develop organically)
- Less competitive rivalry = easier to create stars, consider acquiring a question mark from a competitor
- Dogs may be worth saving if they permit a full range of services that competitors cannot provide